Video: Supply Chain Agility Roundtable | Duration: 1816s | Summary: Supply Chain Agility Roundtable | Chapters: Supply Team Webinar (20.815s), Introducing Expert Panel (104.295s), Rapid Tariff Changes (191.48s), Tariff Impact Observations (313.32498s), Manufacturing Supply Chain Impacts (534.265s), Supply Chain Strategies (635.69s), Managing Tariff Impact (929.89s), Quality Guarantee Differentiation (1290.77s), Tariff Impact Analysis (1409.1901s), Closing and Thanks (1764.2101s)
Transcript for "Supply Chain Agility Roundtable": Okay. Well, welcome everybody. Wanna welcome everybody to our supply team webinar. My name is, Brian Peters, and I'm the CMO at Protolabs, and I'll be your host today. Today, we've got a really exciting panel of experts who will introduce themselves shortly, and we'll be discussing the current tariff landscape and the unique role that digital manufacturing can play in helping navigate the current supply chain disruptions around tariffs. Today, I'm joined by a panel of experts, Janne Christiansen, Luca Mazzi, and Greg Thompson. We'll take a moment now for each of them to introduce themselves before jumping into the q and a. Janne? And there we go. Janne coming in. Why don't we roll with Greg's intro then while we're waiting for Janne to catch up? Yeah. Yeah. Sure. Hi, everybody. Greg Thompson. I'm the senior director of our global network operations, ten year veteran here at Protolabs. I've held roles in our three d printing and CNC factory business. And now I kinda oversee the team that, helps manage our global group of manufacturing partners. Great. Thank you, Greg. Janne, looks looks like you're on stage now. If you can hear us, you can maybe unmute. And go ahead, Janne. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. Hi. I'm Janne Christensen. I'm the, international logistics manager at Protolabs. I've only been with the company for a year, but I have held various roles within the logistics industry for the last two decades, here in The US and in Europe. Great. Thanks, Janne. And Luca, our final guest panelist. Thank you, Brian. Hi, everyone. My name is Luca Mazzei. I'm the strategic growth officer here at Proglance, where for the past two and a half years, I've led the offer and pricing team. And, you know, I have a twenty year career mostly in industrials, you know, both large and small companies, always in the areas of product pricing, and always into the service industrial services area. Go ahead. Well, thanks, all all of you. So that'll be our panel for today of experts. Again, I'll moderate, and we'll start off with some questions, and we will take questions from the audience as well. So I believe you can put your any advanced questions into the chat functions, and the team will be reviewing those. And as as we get towards the end of the webinar, which runs about thirty minutes here, we'll try to feed some of those in. But I'll start with the first question, and I might give this one to Janne. So, Janne, what are the key points to highlight in today's, you know, ever changing tariff landscape? Well, I think first and foremost, it's really important to highlight that even though we knew additional tariffs was gonna come in or increase when Trump took office, what we're experiencing is still very unprecedented. And what makes these times or this time right now, different and extra challenging is, with the speed that we're seeing these new tariffs being implemented, for some of them just, you know, to be changed again, a day or or two later. In fact, that the the changes and the announcements that are made by the White House is at a speed where the US Customs and Border Protection are not able to keep up on their end because they have to interpret, what is coming from the White House so it can be implemented and be, the information being being given out to the custom brokers, within The US so they can process the customs entries correctly. At the time, these entries need to be be done. It is a, challenging time for them. It's a challenging time for us as an importer. So that is definitely the highlights right now is is the speed that we are seeing these things happen. At Protolabs, we definitely recognize that being adapted to all these rapid changes and shifts, is is causing us to have a very crucial and maintaining effective logistic operation, to move the products from a to c. We have to be on top of all these announcements. We have to stay ahead of them if at all possible. And by doing that, we are able to, move our products, your products, with minimal disruptions, to us and, most importantly, to our customers. Great. Thanks, Janne. And, I'm gonna keep moving here, with another question or next question, I should say, for, Greg Thompson. And that's just around, you know, what impact has Protolabs noticed? We're certainly a part of all the tariff changes as well. But what have we seen or noticed, Greg, as we work with our customers? Maybe you can provide us some context on that. Yeah. Sure, Brian. Thanks. Yeah. So I think what what do we notice? I think it's a similar answer to what Janne gave. Right? We've certainly noticed a lot of uncertainty and concern. Endeavor Business Intelligence had a pretty good survey that I think reads the, you know, the mood of the market, you know, and that two thirds of the the people said, hey. Tariffs are probably gonna hurt me. And what was in interesting Alright, Greg. Get a little freeze up there. We'll come back and there we go. Go ahead, Greg. You paused for a minute and you froze. So you're good now. Please finish. Okay. Where did I leave off, Brian? Yeah. You were just talking about how the tariffs are moving faster than supply chains have been able to evolve. So, you know, Endeavor, like I said, half of the people said yeah. So, you know yeah. So so, you know, supply chains are struggling. Right? They're struggling to adapt. They're struggling to evolve at the same pace of change that the tariffs are able to. Right? So a lot of what we've noticed and had conversations with our customers is, you know, around kinda building in some resiliency into their supply chain. But that takes time. Right? And we said in that survey, right, the effects we're all feeling it immediately. Right? So I think the first thing that we've all probably noticed is is pricing. Right? That's been the first move. We've probably seen that in both our our professional and our personal lives. And with those price changes, you know, we've been asked and had a lot of conversations with customers around, you know, can we be an immediate backup? You know, so so bridge supply for business critical components while we see how this cost structure evolves over time. You know, and, you know, I think, you know, that's that's a big piece of it, the the cost themselves was not the only effect. We've seen a lot of kind of ripple effects of the tariffs. I think Janne pointed to this a little bit that we've seen, you know, increases in transit times, you know, delays at customs with outbound and and the, you know, the local country inbound here to The US, A lot of increased demands for documentation. And that's just put a lot of stress overall on teams, suppliers, supply chains as as a whole. So I think the other thing we've noticed and had conversations around is, inventory positions. So it's a lot of strategy that, you know, companies are are considering. We saw kind of a a micro surge at the end of q one. We'll see what happens now with these, you know, the pause of the ninety day, you know, pause to the reciprocals, out of China and, you know, how companies choose or or don't choose to take advantage of that. And I think that's the last point I'd make is, you know, like like on this call. Right? There's there's been a lot of time and mind share put into kinda war gaming or strategizing or scenario planning, how these tariffs may play out. You know, as Janne said, we have literally seen tariffs announced and retracted in literally the same twenty four hour period. So, you know, it's it's really challenging. Right? That that scenario planning is varying degrees of success, and I think that's the big takeaway. Right? What we've noticed is it's a sheer amount of energy and mindshare it takes to try and manage business and its complexities in in such a wildly changing environment. Great. Yep. Thanks, Greg. I know I know the changing environment keeps you very busy, these days. So appreciate you keeping on top of that for us, and our customers. Luca, I may turn to you for the next question. How have the evolving supply chain disruptions affected American manufacturing to date? Well, I think the immediate impact has been, I would say, negative. The PMI reading for April was below 50. That indicates a contraction in manufacturing, and I think that's kind of what we've heard also through industry association. A lot of people are mostly waiting it out, I would say. You know, they're trying to figure out when this is gonna settle to something that is manageable and predictable. So I think that has been a little bit easier on the larger companies who have the both the supply chain flexibility as well as the financial flexibility to maybe build inventories ahead of the tariffs, which had been announced and everybody was expecting, has been certainly more challenging for the smaller company that don't have, you know, that ledger. I think on the longer term though, I you know, nobody seems to believe that this is gonna be the new normal. I think, the one thing that is gonna you know, is here to stay is the uncertainty. And so I think there's gonna be certainly effects in terms of how manufacturers will have put up and continue to be flexible and, you know, and in check you know, not just go after the lowest cost that they've done in the past, but try, you know, you know, be able to manage, you know, the shift, in a much more flexible way that they've done in the past. Good. And, Luca, stay with me here because I'm gonna maybe have you start with the next question here a little bit, then maybe, Greg, I'll have you, chime in. But what steps can manufacturers take to lower cost for customers, during the supply chain, disruption? And we'll we'll start with that. I will say I'm gonna add one that's come in in the chat that's related to this, and that's around just how our pricing is changing with our customers if it's changing. So So when you think about our factory pricing where we do domestic production in The US, and then we have a network, where some of those partners are outside of The US in tariff, countries, you know, what have we done or how are we passing or not passing along that pricing? So that'll be a part two. I just want you to know that. But related to that, Luca, I'll let you start, you know, with, you know, what steps can we take, during this. Yeah. So, I think that the, I would say, the the easy answer, much easier said than done, is to start, you know, developing supply chains which are more flexible and resilient. Again, this is, you know, you know, kind of a simple statement, but it means a lot, even for large companies that do have the that flexibility because very often, they have much bigger operations, and some of these projects they time and they're not kind of, you know, something that you can flip the switch and just, you know, you know, change your overall supply chain in six months or even a year, sometimes longer than that. So that's kind of the the the obvious answer. I think part of that can be done, you know, leveraging kind of partners that can help you do that, and I think that's kind of the role that we've been playing with some of our customers, both because we have kind of a, you know, kind of a mixed model where we have both US based factories, which are basically gonna be much more insulated than all of this, as well as we have this network model that maybe Greg can take on. You know? So that offers us the flexibility to, you know, help customers, you know, react quickly and then, you know, use this as a bridge to their future supply chain status quo, whatever that's gonna be. Greg, maybe if you wanna add something specifically on the network side. Yeah. Thanks, Luca. I I guess I'll answer this in terms of the the value that we can bring in helping, you know, kinda control control the cost. And we do that kinda two ways. You know, one is is around the strategies we employ to just limit the overall customs impact to to our customers overall, and the the second is around kind of the breadth of services that we support with. So for first, on that first part, you know, we are the importer of record, for all of our transactions. So we're gonna handle all of the customs, you know, for you that be that the, you know, the documentation, the imports, the the rates, the the clearance, all of the logistics. And in doing that, you know, we make sure that you're only charged on the overseas imported value. So you'll hear people refer to that as kind of the first sale strategy, you know, highly successful and and pretty standard. And and so we do a lot of that for you. I think secondly and probably more importantly, you know, we can help you optimize for what you need. Right? So if you're trying to optimize for cost, if you're trying to optimize for speed, you know, it really depends on your particular situation and your particular need. Right? And, you know, we can even help you kind of build up different options for each, be it prototype or for for production. Right? You know, Luca pointed to this. Right? It's not really feasible, you know, for a a lot of companies to have a a diverse group of partners, to to build that up and then to maintain it. Right? That's exceptionally challenging. But without regional diversity, you're gonna be subject to the risk of, you know, whatever potential change happens in your your primary basis of supply. Right? And so, you know, those are just facts, but it's not feasible again to to build it up. But we can and we do. And so, you know, that's on top of our our owned factories in in The US and and in Europe. And so, we really try and serve, you know, the needs of your project, at the time in the most value and efficient way. I think I'll tease a little bit of your your second question to come, Brian, because I think we we also wanna support in a very transparent way. And so, you know, as we quote, we quote fully landed prices, and I think that's one thing that I would advise, you know, the the groups of folks, you know, listening in. You know, as you're working fast here, as you're evaluating your supply chains and potential new partners, you know, make sure that you're looking at the the entirety of the costs. We we quote fully landed because we don't want there to be kinda any understated risk or unexpected cost coming your way. There was enough uncertainty happening with tariffs in and on themselves. Right? You don't need any more kinda risk coming at you from your partners. That's that's for sure. Good. And do you so in terms of just while we're on the topic. Right? The question that came in is just how are we passing on, rolling along, how we're treating the tariffs with our customers. And I think we should talk about that both from impact to factory, which is U. S. Based, right? There's no tariff on that other than probably the raw materials coming in that we use, and we can talk about that. And then in the network, remember, we're in multiple countries that all have different tariffs around the globe, and so, you know, there's some variance there. But I don't know, Greg or Luca, if you wanna give a high level summary of how tariffs have, maybe financially or pricing wise, impacted our customers' business with us. Yes. Sure. Maybe we'll divide and conquer this as well, Brian. I'll take the factory and Greg, I think, has a lot more depth also specifically on the network operation side. But for factory, as you said, the impact for us has been really minimal. You know? Number one, the factories are in US. I think the biggest tariff that really kind of impacted us there are the aluminum and steel, 25% tariff for imported. Most of our material and aluminum steels come from overseas, and at this point, this is relevant where it comes from. I think the the advantage that I think we have had, you know, compared to the average, you know, manufacturer here is that the cost of material for us is kind of on average, a lower part of the total cost mostly because we have, you know, a high degree of automation. You know, that's kind of the the digital manufacturing that was kind of at the root, of the company when it started, you know, and has continued to this day. So, certainly, we're we're gonna you know, eventually, we're gonna have to pass some of that, and we're gonna make adjustments to the price. But I would say in the bigger context, you know, especially once you hear this big number, that's really kind of minor. And we certainly seen as we monitor competitive pricing in the marketplace, you know, much higher increases, you know, from our competition, you know, both online and not. So that's, I think, it's been an advantage of our model in this, you know, in this, you know, at this stage of, where we are with these tariffs. You know, I think the situation is a little bit more complex in, on the network side. But, Greg, I I think maybe you can take that on. Yeah. You know, in in terms of how we're managing, you know, the tariffs, you know, into our pricing, we certainly account for for customs and customs rates in our in our pricing. And as I said, we we make sure that we are very transparent by giving a fully landed price. So you know what you're paying upfront, you know, before you click order with us. You know, as far as kinda managing, you know, all all of that, you know, I I will say, you know, we do have experts like Donna, you know, in in terms of mitigating the the expenses of of the customs. Right? There is a lot of industries or applications, where, you know, they they may qualify for an exclusion or a far more advantage tariff rate than what we kinda see and hear about in in the news. You know? And so we can we can take advantage of that for sure. You know, I think the other thing that we can take advantage of, right, we, you know, we we talked about kinda diversity in in the supply chains overall. Right? Like, we can just we can put the work where it makes the most sense. So I think that's the biggest way that we kinda keep tariffs from hitting hitting the customers, right, is to make sure that we're advantaging is all possible kinda, you know, how we classify the work and where we source the work. Good. Hey. So I'm gonna stay with it for a minute. Mhmm. Greg, because there's a sort of a I like this question. It's sort of a part two question, but it's related to, you know, where where should I manufacture my stuff now? And and so this question's about, look, if if will the parts manufactured in The US reduce the cost of the product as compared to maybe in the past where I would have produced them overseas? And how should I think about that as a customer? And I know it depends, but maybe, Greg, you can put some color commentary on that for the audience. Yeah. I think, you know, the way I would say that is, we, you know, we've got the advantage of having kind of a global group of partners, right, that service, you know, a business that's global as well, and it represents this huge range of materials and manufacturing processes. So, you know, we can put the work where it makes the most sense. I think that you know, so a good example. Right? Our our additive business, we locally source all of our three d printing in The United States. And so, you know, that has been unaffected by tariffs whatsoever. And, you know, given the the lead times, the customers often demand out of that service and, you know, the, just the cost base, it makes the most sense to to source. Right? So from a US tariff perspective, unaffected. You know, for c and c and injection molding, we're we're going to source in, you know, the most advantage area as as possible. Right? So, oftentimes, there are less affected areas by tariffs, at least in recent times here. You know, so we we'll choose India or Mexico or The United States. Now, frankly, in a lot of times, right, like, China actually makes the most sense. The, you know, and so we're we're gonna choose that. Right? I think we we built up that expertise. We talked about with Diana. We built up this big group of of partners. Right? And so I think, you know, it's we we are going to take advantage of that diversity to minimize the impact for for you. And again, the cost base of all these, you know, countries differs wildly. So it really depends on the certifications, the complexity of the part, you know, the type of material. All of those drastically affect the tariff. So I think, you know, what I would say is, you know, we're we're gonna find the most advantage location and we're gonna make sure that, you know, the back end of that is really, you know, undisrupted for you as as our customer. Good. Well, good. There's some more pricing questions we'll come back to in the chat. That's awesome. We'll have some time for that. On back, I'll pivot back in a moment. But I'm gonna ask, a question of Luca here. And that is how else, or how else does Protolabs differentiate its offering in terms of and for supply chain agility? I think one of the key differentiating factors that we kind of bring to the table on top of what, you know, Greg has been describing, is that we have this kind of unique quality guarantee that sort of covers both of our, you know, factory and network offering. You know, customers very often, you know, buy, you know, parts of an assembly, you know, and some of them we do in the factory. Some of them we manufacture, you know, here in US through the network or outside of US through the network. But the customer can knows that, you know, we're gonna be basically help holding all of those parts to the same quality standards. So we inspect most of the parts that would before we ship them to customers, whether they come from the factory or from the network. So I think that's really a unique, you know, feature that we bring, you know, to this. I think that's also kind of the consequence of the type of model of network model that we've kind of chosen. We instead of going for the quantity, just having the most number of partners possible, we have a much smaller network but much more curated network of partners that we kind of really, get close to, understand how they can work, how they can produce part to our standards. And, therefore, we can, you know, get both the speed, you know, the quality, and, you know, sometimes the price point that the customers are looking for when they're looking to differentiate. So I think that's really a unique, you know, piece that is gonna be very, very hard to replicate either through our competition, but also if you wanna do it in house. You know? It's, it it requires a lot of time and effort to build, you know, that type of capability. Good. Good. Well, let me pivot back to the some of the chat questions here, and and I'll open it up to anybody on the panel here, you know, you know, to answer this next one. But it's around parts that have long lead times. Right? So we might have production orders or whatever that are sixty, ninety days out from time of order to, you know, time of delivery. How is the pricing is the pricing locked in regardless of what the tariffs were and will be if they change? You know, how does the customer think about that? Yeah. I think I can jump in on that one, Brian. So, you know, actually, at this point, we we do, lock our quotes and commit to our quotes for, you know, thirty days in our network orders or sixty days on our factory orders, you know, generally. So, yeah, we're locked in. Right? Like, if there are changes into the tariffs from when they were ordered to when they land, you know, we're gonna absorb that risk. So I think, Janne, I think you were the one that asked earlier around, you know, are we passing, you know, prices on to to our customers as little as possible. Right? We're trying to manage and mitigate any of the customs impact as much as possible. But, yeah, you know, right now as things stand, we are locking those prices in. I think where we've really worked with customers on the network side is in our injection molding business where we've got, you know, tools in place in in a country that got disproportionately affected by tariffs and what do we do for the past subsequent part orders. So we've worked with customers quite a bit around that. So, but, yeah, within thirty days, those prices are locked. We're gonna commit to that. Good. Good. Hey. We're just, at slightly under. We're actually at the four minute mark, and we will end on time, but we've got a couple more questions here we'll try to squeeze in. And this one's around, you know, we source raw materials for our domestic factories. Right? Steel and aluminum. Are we gonna begin sourcing those domestically, you know, without a tariff? Or is it still cheaper for us, for example, to import that those products with the tariff? So what does our supply chain look like in terms of raw materials? And, Greg Thompson, maybe that's best for you to also, chime in on. Yeah. Well, in terms of raw materials for our factories, you know, obviously, they're a second and and third tier of supply that we have to account for in, you know, in in where where they're sourced, how they're tracked, you know, and, you know, the the cost of those. So I think, you know, we've we've got a full supply procurement team that's working that. I think right now, you know, we we domestically source, you know, the materials themselves, but the second and third tier are likely coming from overseas. Right? And so, you know, we're gonna continually manage that. And, again, as I said, on the network side, we're gonna mitigate those effects for the factory side as well. So from the factory, that's kinda in the second and third tier where it becomes non non domestic if at all. You know, for our overseas, you know, most of those are sourced within country. Right? So our partners that are in China are sourcing out of out of China and likewise in India. Good. You know, one more. It's a good topic, pricing and all that, of course. And this one, again, I'll open it up to the panel. Anybody can take it. But is the imported value of a product using steel and aluminum less the cost of labor to build the product, hardware and components that aren't steel and aluminum? You know, are there clear tariff guidelines? Who determines these guidelines? So I'll pop that to the panel. Yeah. I guess I'll jump in. Oh, yeah. Go ahead, Luca. No. I mean, I was gonna say that, you know, I was gonna just make a quick mark. You know? I I think going to to the original answer from Janne at the very beginning, you know, very often some of those rules get, you know, tariffs get pub published, but there's really not a lot of direction. So there's been, for the time being, a lot of discretion. And, you know, we've been going back and forth with a lot of our, you know, custom officers around, you know, duties that we've been charged for that I think, that we think are, you know, not correct. But in theory, yes, the you know, for components made out of steel and aluminum that come from overseas, the the steel and aluminum tax or, you know, tariffs only applies to the, you know, the, you know, the steel and aluminum component of the value of that part. Now how that's computed? You know, I think we try to stay close to kind of the actual, cost that our suppliers give us. But, obviously, that can get questions, I'm assuming, you know, from the customer officials, and there is the, you know, you know, the possibility that that's gonna be, you know, a challenge. But, Greg, maybe you I know that you've done a lot of analysis on the plan on that, so we're doing that at some specifically. Yeah. I think just for context to the to the broader audience, we're talking about the derivative value of the steel, on what was the section two three two tariffs that got implemented back in mid March. Right? So, you know, for raw aluminum raw steel, that was the target of of that tariff. You know, those those were, you know you know, charged at the full 25 percent for any imported value of it. You know, what we're talking about here is even for any good or component that is compromised of of steel or comprised of steel and aluminum, right, You still owe a derivative effect. And so as we read it and as we've worked with our our broker, you know, customs broker and, again, to to Luca's point, it's a lot of conversation because not all of this is is applied evenly across all the different brokers. Right? There's a lot of uncertainty out there as Janne pointed to you and and Luca pointed out. So we do believe it is of the value of steel or aluminum of your total your total good. Right? And you will pay kind of the 25% derivative effect of the $2.03 2 on that. Janne. Well, look. That was action packed. We are at time. So that's all the time we have for today. And I wanted to thank you so much for our panel and, of course, to the audience for a great q and a session. We will post, this recorded webinar to Protolabs.combackslashevents, next week, and you will be able to access the presentation then if you'd like. So, again, thank you all for joining the webinar, and thank you, panel, and I hope you have a wonderful day. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you.